Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length

 
Advanced search

163 Posts in 57 Topics- by 661 Members - Latest Member: karenheineman771

September 04, 2010, 01:49:03 PM
Micca Community ForumProduct DiscussionsFiiO ProductsFiiO S9 Review - Portable Speaker System For MP3 Players
Pages: [1]
Print
Author Topic: FiiO S9 Review - Portable Speaker System For MP3 Players  (Read 2059 times) Share this topic on FacebookShare this topic on Del.icio.usShare this topic on DiggShare this topic on RedditShare this topic on StumbleUponShare this topic on Twitter
Jack
Global Moderator
Jr. Member
*****
Posts: 79


« on: September 24, 2009, 09:30:14 AM »

The FiiO S9 crossed my sights when we were looking for high quality small portable speaker to add to the products offered by Micca. The small speaker market is filled with cheaply made products using tiny metallic cones that looked and sounded horrible. As an audio enthusiast, I could appreciate that good sounding small portable speakers are a tough design goal due to the triple-constraint of low power, small enclosure, and small cone area. On paper, the FiiO S9 appears to address these challenges in creative ways, so I was cautiously optimistic as I received the first batch of products at our Virginia office.


In the box along with the FiiO S9 are a USB Y-cable, a 3.5mm male-male audio cable, and a short but well written user's manual in both English and Chinese. The S9 consists primarily of a white enclosure made from what looks to be very high quality plastic, accentuated with a black cloth grill on the front. There is a single port-like opening in the front, but it does not actually provide any acoustic output as the real ports are on the back of the speaker behind each driver. Also on the back is a compartment for four AA batteries, a USB jack for power, and a 3.5mm input jack. The top of the S9 has four buttons for power, +/- volume, and mute. In all, it's a neat, tidy and intuitively designed product that looks to be of very good quality and elegant in design and appearance. Underneath this well put together exterior lies the technology that FiiO has employed to address each of the three constraints mentioned earlier.


Before going further into the hardware aspects of the S9, I spent a couple of weeks listening to it in place of my main computer speakers (Creative Labs Z2300). I also used it with a variety of portable sources, including notebooks, various MP3 players and a couple of music-capable cell phones.

At first listen, the FiiO S9 immediately impressed me with the rich and full sound it produced – I grinned uncontrollably and knew that we had found exactly the small speakers that we were looking for. Not only does the S9 playback over a frequency range wide enough to qualify as high fidelity, but it does so evenly and smoothly, with plenty of quality and definition. The sound is airy and effortlessness without any harshness or strain. The most beautiful part of the output is the mid-range, with both male and female vocals coming through sounding very intimate and believable, loaded with detail and resolution. So often, the mid-range of small speakers are sacrificed in order to makeup for shortcomings in other areas, but not so for the S9. The highs from the S9 are also done right, adding well controlled sizzle in all the right spots without being harsh. The treble parts of instruments and vocals therefore sound very natural. The S9 probably does not extend all the way flat to 20kHz, but it should be good for a honest and high quality 13-15kHz, which is plenty for listening to most music types in a casual setting.

The bass section of the S9 deserves separate treatment. The FiiO S9 can't perform magic, so it is unable to produce real bass in the bottom octave. But what it does produce is incredibly good for its size and power. When placed on a desk thus benefiting from the base-plane reinforcement, I would say that the speaker does an excellent job of reaching down to about 100Hz and then rolling off after that at a characteristic 12dB/octave slope, giving the listener a “hint” of 60Hz on its way down. I would best describe the S9 as having a lean sound characteristic similar to British speakers, with well defined and bass that is very musical and well controlled. Even at high volume, the bass is taught, even, and punchy.


Speaking of high volume, the S9 can reach pretty shocking playback levels that makes you wonder what normal speakers are doing with all that power if something this small with only 3.6 Watts can rock so hard. The clean output ceiling of the S9 is perfectly capable of filling an office or bedroom with loud music with peaks in the low 90dB range.

The next part needs to be heard to be believed: the FiiO S9 produces honest to goodness imaging. You read that right – the S9 projects a sound stage with vocals, instruments, ambiance, the whole nine. If you didn't think small speakers would be capable of real stereo performance, you need to give the S9 a listen. With the S9 placed on a desk, the sound stage was projected about 12 inches above it, just below nose level. It's not particularly wide, but it's there and very real. I don't know how FiiO managed to accomplish this at the price level of the S9, as it takes proper (i.e. expensive) amplifier and enclosure design, as well as tight driver tolerances with excellent left/right channel tracking and matching to achieve good imaging results.

So after two weeks of extended subjective listening with a good variety of music and playback environments, I came away thoroughly enamored by the FiiO S9. It's a breath of fresh air that something so compact can perform so well while offering a classy understated look. The S9 truly sets the bar for what a small speaker is capable of.
Logged
Jack
Global Moderator
Jr. Member
*****
Posts: 79


« Reply #1 on: September 24, 2009, 09:33:49 AM »

The above is about where most reviews would stop. The product gets an adequate description, the reviewer offers subjective impression, and hopefully the readers come away with a good idea of what to expect from the product. But I really wanted to learn more about the S9, to see why it was capable of the performance that it has demonstrated. So, I dug in further to find out exactly how the S9 manages to deal with the three constraints of low power, small enclosure, and small cone area.

The grill is made from a plastic mesh frame covered in black grill cloth. The grill is glued in place and removing it will damage the speaker and the grill. But once removed, I was treated to the sight of two serious looking drivers.


Treated paper cone drivers are especially suited to relatively simple speakers due to the inherent excellent self-damping characteristic, providing excellent resolution, detail, and a flat response without needing complex crossovers or enclosure design to tame resonance. The on-set of cone break-up is also very gentle and even acoustically pleasing – this is the very reason why all speakers used for amplified instruments such as electric guitars are made with paper cones. Paper cone is a very popular choice for high end midrange and full range drivers. It is therefore not surprising that the S9 offers such nice midrange reproduction.


This is a magnificent little driver. It measures approximately 60mm across edges of the surround. It employs a huge magnet for superior efficiency and power handling. A large magnet structure provides better damping of cone motion, starting and stopping cone motion more quickly. The 5mm half-roll foam surround by itself is not that noteworthy, but together with the large and compliant spider assembly, indicates that this driver is designed for a relatively large x-max, which is critical for high output capabilities given the limited cone area, especially at low frequencies. Together with the ported enclosure design, this little speaker moves a lot of air as is evident by putting one's hand near the rear port while the S9 is playing at a high volume.


Sharp eyed readers may notice that the dust cap on this driver looks a bit odd. This is in fact a very interesting design element of this driver that greatly extends and improves its natural high frequency response. To start, the dust cap is made from a different paper material that is more suitable for high frequency reproduction. The dust cap is mated directly to the voice coil former rather than glued to the cone. This effectively decouples the dust cap from the damping effects of the cone in a gradual manner and turns the dust cap into a mini tweeter. Lastly, the dust cap has a half-dome shape for superior dispersion characteristics.

In this day an age of kevlar/ceramic/aluminum speakers, a paper cone driver may not seem all that impressive. But it is all about suitability to task, and as they say, the devil is in the details.


Removing the driver reveals a ported enclosure. A large square of acoustic matting fills most of the enclosure to increase the effective enclosure volume while providing damping and attenuation of standing waves. The enclosure is meticulously sealed with a glue-like compound to guard against air leaks – this makes the enclosure port much more effective and consistent in performance. The enclosure is basically cylindrical in shape, with the front and rear plates braced by a collection of ridges and posts. The left and right drivers each have their own enclosure that are completely separate and do not even share a common wall. Here again, we see the methodical good design principles practiced by FiiO engineers and making most out of what's available.


Portable speakers have traditionally been underpowered due to limited power available from batteries or through USB. Theoretically, a USB Y-cable plugged into two USB ports is able to provide a maximum of 1A current at 5 Volts for total maximum output of 5 Watts. Most USB speakers are able to get only 1 to 2 Watts of power out of the available 5. The FiiO S9, however, employs highly efficient Class-D amplifier that achieves over 70% power efficiency at most output volume levels. This translates into 3.6 Watts of available clean power, or 1.8 Watts for each channel. The high efficiency also means that batteries last a long time – a freshly charged set of four AA Sanyo Eneloop batteries lasted well over a week of 2-3 hours of daily listening at a normal level. Peering through the opening at the front of the S9, I was able to see a part of the amplifier board, some power capacitors, and what appears to be a heat sink for the amplifier chip.


While putting the S9 back together, I couldn't wait to write down what I had learned and share it with others looking for a small portable speaker. The FiiO S9 certainly doesn't break any barriers in terms of raw performance. What it has gotten so right, is a nearly perfect mixture of features and capability, that makes it more suitable for casual portable music listening and sharing than any other small speaker we've seen.
Logged
Jack
Global Moderator
Jr. Member
*****
Posts: 79


« Reply #2 on: October 23, 2009, 06:35:33 AM »

We have gotten a lot of positive feedback from buyers regarding the FiiO S9. Here is just a sample of what we've received:

Amazon.com review:
"We took the FiiO S9 camping with us to use with the mp3 player. Wow! Really great sound and volume. I really like that it uses AA batteries, rather than something that would have to be recharged. I would highly recommend this product to anyone. Time will tell how long it will last, but it looks and sounds like a quality system. Great value!!"

Ebay Feedback:
"Very impressed , gonna need more for Christmas gifts . A+ Ebayer"

"Enjoying the sound, thanks."

"Great sound !! FAST shipping !! A+ transaction !! Thank you !!!"

"Great product, and terrific service. Thanks"

"Excellent seller. Great product. Great prices. Fast shipping. Thanks!"

"Great portable speaker!"


The FiiO S9 is truly an exceptional product and we are extremely happy that so many customers have found it to be as enjoyable as we have.
Logged
Pages: [1]
Print
Jump to:  


Theme orange-lt created by padexx